Jonathan Lopez
asked this on July 26, 2010 01:35 pm
I used it for a project and simply didn't finish it because it took so long to work in it. The current version is too imprecise! I just wound up using Photoshop for designing up everything...
It would be great to have a download for Macs and PCs like on Mpix.
Comments
Jonathan, we have many plans for the Photo Book designer and will be updating it constantly over the coming months. The features we will be adding, and the order we add them in will be strongly influenced my customers such as yourself. One of the reasons we created these forums is because we want customer feedback on what you want to see, what you like, what you don't, and especially what you need. Please yell us what you need and why you need it, and use the "Me Too" button to vote for the features you need. Doing that will help us assign priorities for upcoming development.
If you could elaborate on which aspects you found imprecise, it would be a big help. The more details you can provide on what's missing, or how we could meet your needs better, the quicker we can accommodate them.
Thanks!
Items needed for the Photo Book. 1) style sheets, so that once I decide on a border and shadow I can use that style for every image quickly. Check out InDesign or Quark style sheets 2) Custom designing was sooo slooow!! I work on a MAC everyday as a graphic designer and this was very time consuming. 3) Photos jumped around too easily even using the exact coordinates. If I want the photo to start at 90 and be 180 tall then it should not move when I make it taller. It should only expand in one direction, from the top not the center. 4) Custom number of pages is a must...I was forced to make the book 38 pages when I only needed 34. 5) need inches for the size of photos, could not tell if my photos were 4x6 or not. 6) I could not pull guides into the page from the ruler to measure anything. 6) need a trim line on the layout so we will know the trim. 7) asking us if we want photo correction AFTER we create our book....no, no. no....we should know what that means before we import our photos, and no where on the import section does it specify this...so I spent several days touching up my photo when I did not need to. Or at least I do not think I needed to....I guess I will wait for the final book on this. 8) magnification bar needs to give us a percentage indicator. If I shoot with a high resolution then I know I can enlarge photos but your zoom bar does not give a percentage so i do not know how large I can make my photo accurately. I tried Shutterfly and was very disappointed with the quality of the final product. i hope you will do better!!
Some great points Quin, thank you! I agree with most of your suggestions and a few are already in the works. A couple of clarifications please. When you say designing was too slow, can you elaborate? Are you referring to application performance, connection speed, UI issues, workflow? By magnification bar - you are referring to zooming/cropping an image?
Thanks,
AL
Yes, Slow application performance, and workflow, NOT connection speed, I have a fast cable network. Slow also because the photos imported could not be quickly listed in the order taken so I had to scroll much too often and could not see the whole name of a photo. Yes, the zooming/cropping bar...if I could see that the photo was magnified 20% or 50% then I would know if my resolution was workable or not. Also, I wanted to copy certain left-hand layouts with photos and type to a right-hand page but could only select everything on the whole spread. Need a bounding box selector that allows me to decide what I want to copy or a way to group items so they can be duplicated and moved easily. If you are not familiar with InDesign or Quark MASTER pages then check them out. It is sort of like letting us design our own templates. Your template selection was VERY limited. I would love to design some for you...any job opportunity here?
The idea of offering a photo book palette online is excellent. And you have many great features. However, the process involves too many steps, the uploads are awkward and time consuming to deal with, and the whole book software slows down when the book reaches about 70% full...sometimes even freezing, and requiring a re-boot. In order of preference, here are my suggestions:
See if you can eliminate some steps. Why do we need to lay in a gray photo background for each type of layout. Isn't there a way to design it s one can just drag the photo into a page or spread and resize it. Having to a) format the page background color, b) Format the photo backgroound, c) drag in the photo, d) resize it, and undo it all if the photo doesn't fit is way too time consuming. I think I spent 40 hours creating the last book, and I had done four before that. The uploading process is awkward, time consuming, and as someone else mentioned, one should be able to keep the order they were uploaded in so one can organize the book in advance. You do have a auto load feature. But if it were flexible enough to "read" the photos that are pre-ordered, and lay in all the backgrounds automoatically to match the photo size (and format chosen), this would save days of work.
I would like to echo Quin's sentiments. I've been playing with your editor for about an hour and a half and I want to shoot myself. I suppose if I just wanted a cutesy album for a kid's birthday party this would be fine, but for any kind of design work this is not a viable solution.
I am going to design everything in either Photoshop or In-Design, but I'm worried about how the text will come out. Also, your information on bleeds seems, shall we say, less than precise.
I was excited to create a family history album. I have hundreds of old photos. First, I don't know how many pages I need. Second, the don't want to use predetermined photo sizes. Whoever designed your photo layouts should have gathered old photos. Most old photos are vertical. I didn't seem to have the option to re-size my photos to exactly what a I wanted. I wish the family tree backgrounds were available in the other type photo books. Give a bunch of us genealogists the chance to help you design a great family tree album. I emailed my questions to Adorama and got NO response. It was so disappointing.
the calendar template is clunky. You should be able to reapply a new template to an existing calendar instead of needing to start over; and go in and modify an old calendar to create a new calendar.
Frederick Donner writes:
See if you can eliminate some steps. Why do we need to lay in a gray photo background for each type of layout. Isn't there a way to design it s one can just drag the photo into a page or spread and resize it.
Hi Frederick. You don't need to drag a placeholder onto the page first. You can just drag your photo onto the page and then resize it. The placeholders are a time-saving option for pre-made templates. i.e. we can pre-size and position photo placeholders to save you tedious resizing and positioning. If you drag any photo to a spot on a page that isn't over an existing placeholder, it just adds it to the page.
Hi Cheryl. To address your questions.
1. Choosing from a fixed number of pages is a limitation of our current binding system and not something we can easily change.
2. Actually I designed that album Cheryl. I based it loosely on an album I got from my mother filled with photos from the 30's through the 60's. The ratio of vertical to horizontal photos in my mother's album is about 40% vertical to 60% horizontal. Perhaps your comment about the majority of photos being vertical reflects a different time period, or perhaps my family was unusual in this regard. Either way, you aren't limited to the pre-made layouts. Just click the grey bar at the bottom left of PixPublisher called "Layouts" and drag one of the layouts with vertically oriented placeholders over to your spread to replace it.
Another option is to choose one of the vertical book sizes - the 12x9 for example. As a rule of thumb, there are generally more horizontal placeholders in the landscape sized books than in the portrait sized books since the shape of the page tends to more easily accommodate that style of photo.
3. I'm not sure what you mean by being unable to resize them to exactly what you want. You should be able to just grab the corner of your photo and resize however you like. In the case of the heritage album there is the added complication of the sticker behind each photo which creates the old-style scalloped-edge. After resizing the photo, you'll need to grab the corner of the sticker and resize it as well. Or you could just delete the sticker and go with a standard border - possibly in an eggshell color if you want it to match.
4. The feature to make layouts from one book theme available in other books is planned for the future.
By all means if you have suggestions for a family tree album, I'd be happy to discuss it with you. Maybe I can create another heritage album that's more in line with what you're looking for.
Regards,
AL
Hi Maureen, can you elaborate on which calendar template you were having challenges with?
I believe I started with the Contemporary and wanted to change to Modern in the middle. it would be nice to be able to apply a different template to your calendar without everything being switched around. Is "autofill" a default setting? Also, it would be nice to go back and edit a calendar later with some modifications, to be able to customize for different people.
Thanks. Quality on the printout looks great. the website indicated an earlier delivery time however for Christmas.
oh, and i was getting a lot of server error messages while i was making the calendar, and lost work along the way.
I would also like to see some features. As such, the ability to change a photograph from being square to a crop of a circle would be great. I had done an album where I had a few pictures that were already circle shaped and had to have them with a square background. Is this a possibility?
Hi Amy. We are in the testing phase of a new version right now. As fortune would have it, one of the features included in the new version is image masks which allow an extensive range of shapes to be applied to your photos. You should be seeing that new version soon.
In the interim however, we do have circular sticker-masks. Open the stickers library, type mask in the search box and they should pup up. As long as you have a solid colored background you can recolor the sticker to the same color and apply it over your photo.
Hope this helps.
AL